Daily Fantasy Sports Companies Wait on NY Decision

10 December 2015

New york

Daily fantasy sports have been having a really hard time over the past couple of months. It started off with a handful of states deciding that the service was against their online gambling and/or sweepstakes laws, and then there was the scandal. This scandal involved a DraftKings employee using inside information to pull six figures in winnings in one weekend at FanDuel. Now they're facing an injunction from the Attorney General of New York, and the court case surrounding it is going to be a critical point for the industry in North America.

The Source of the Issue

Attorney General Eric Schneiderman filed an application for an injunction in mid-November that would force DraftKings and FanDuel out of the New York market. While FanDuel decided to just move along and stop accepting NY players, DraftKings has contested the issue and taken them to court. Judge Manuel Mendez is overseeing the case, and he has already heard arguments from both sides. He's expected to make a decision anytime on this issue.

Schneiderman's argument centers on the idea that daily fantasy sports is predominantly chance-based, and that would make it illegal to play online in the state of New York. DraftKings contends that it's skill-based. The issue between the skill-based and chance-based nature of the game was bound to happen sooner or later, since it's the key criterion used to determine the legality of certain types of wagering in many states. Now it's happening on one of the largest stages in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York.

Implications of the Case

Under New York's rules, something like online slots would clearly be illegal, but playing in a paid chess tournament would be clearly legal. A lot of other games fall somewhere between the two on the spectrum.

This is also a case where the fantasy sports carve-out in the UIGEA doesn't help the daily fantasy companies because state law can still make something illegal if it has a carve-out in that particular act. What this means is that this single court case could be the most important ruling that we've seen so far in the DFS industry, and the decision could impact the entire future of the industry as well since other states will likely follow New York's lead on the skill vs. chance debate.

Related News

  • 06 February 2016

    Vantiv to Suspend Daily Fantasy Sports Payments

    For the past six months or so, daily fantasy sports have been dealt setback after setback in what seems to be a series of dominoes that are taking their sweet time in falling over. For about 18 months, the top DFS providers got a ton of attention through aggressive marketing tactics and sponsorships and deals with everything from ESPN to major league sports teams. After a scandal broke last fall, they've seen a lot of negative attention as well. The Most Recent Developments Vantiv Inc.

    Read full article
  • 21 January 2016

    Daily Fantasy Sports Not Allowed Says Maryland AG

    Over the past few months, there have been a lot of questions about the legality of daily fantasy sports in multiple states. The Attorney General for New York sent a cease and desist letter to major companies like FanDuel and DraftKings, and they also hit some resistance from the AG in Illinois. Now the Attorney General of Maryland Brian Frosh has stated that it's not allowed under existing laws in the state. Where to Go From Here From here, Frosh has suggested one of two things.

    Read full article
  • 19 January 2016

    Daily Fantasy Sports May or May Not Be Illegal in Texas

    Daily fantasy sports have come under fire in New York from their Attorney General, and the biggest names in the business were forced to make a deal with the AG from Illinois after she determined that the events were illegal in that state as well. The Attorney General in Texas, however, is taking his sweet time with coming out with an opinion on the matter.

    Read full article